Calphalon Signature vs Premier: Which Is The Best Cookware For You?

When it comes to cookware sets, like the All-Clad Cookware, Calphalon is one of the trusted and tested brands these days. Over the years, Calphalon has already made different lines of cookware consisting of various pans, pots, and even plates.

Two of the most known cookware lines offered by Calphalon are Premier and Signature. Both can be a great option if you want to invest in quality, versatile, and long-lasting cookware sets.

If your problem is that you can’t decide between these two products, be sure to read this Calphalon Signature vs Premier review.

In today’s article, I will show you the difference between Signature and Premier so that you can easily make a decision.

After reading this post, I can assure you that you’ll be able to get the cookware set that will suit your needs, cooking styles, and even budget.

Calphalon Signature Overview

Calphalon Signature vs Premier: Which Is The Best Cookware For You? 1 #cookymom

Pros

  • The Calphalon will last for years, thanks to the durability that the hard-anodized aluminum offers.
  • It is very easy to clean.
  • It can be used on any kind of stove like ceramic glass, gas, induction, and electric.
  • The cookware pieces heat evenly because of the hard-anodized aluminum

Cons

  • The cooking surface contains PTFE, but it is not a big deal, as the cookware set is proven safe to use for cooking.
  • The nonstick coating is not as effective as other cookware sets offered by Calphalon.

The Calphalon Signature is more durable compared to standard pans and pots. The cookware’s base comprises three layers of hard-anodized and heavy-gauge aluminum. Two layers of stainless steel fuse them.

The exterior and interior surfaces are also infused using advanced release polymer. This material can make a microscopic layer of high-performing fiber binding the metal. And the outcome is a very nonstick surface that will not easily fade away.  

With Calphalon Signature, you can use metal utensils. It is also dishwasher-safe. On the other hand, the nonstick sear coating is solid. Thus it does not warp, chip, and bend quickly compared to other pans.

The stainless-steel cookware can be safely used on induction stoves, electric rings, glass tops, halogen, gas, and electricity. On the other hand, the nonstick variety of Calphalon Signature is suitable for glass top ranges, electric rings, gas, electric, and halogen.

The Calphalon Signature does a great job when it comes to heat distribution. You will get accurate temperature control that is beneficial when prepping specific dishes. With this cookware set, you can also monitor the progress of what you are cooking with ease, thanks to its glass lids.

Another great thing about the Signature line is that it is oven-sage up to 500-degree Fahrenheit. However, it’s highly recommended to stick to 450-degree Fahrenheit. Also, you will need to restrict the use of lids in the oven.

The coating has PTFE that can release toxins, particularly at an extreme temperature.

Check out the full Calphalon Signature Reviews

Calphalon Premier Overview

Calphalon Signature vs Premier: Which Is The Best Cookware For You? 2 #cookymom

Pros

  • All pans and pots are compatible with glass and electric stovetops and gas.
  • Safe to utilize metal utensils
  • It has a strong three-layer nonstick coating
  • All pans are dishwasher-safe

Cons

  • It is quite expensive
  • Some pots come with small handles

The Calphalon Premier will help you with almost everything like chicken recipes without taking too much space in your counter or kitchen.

Every pan and pot that comes in this cookware set stacks smaller as each piece has a recessed button that is ideal for simple stacking needs and storage. The good thing is that you can nest and stack the cookware pieces in any order.

Every cookware set sports a hard-anodized aluminum body with stainless handles that remain cool while cooking. When it comes to the nonstick surface, it can handle different kinds of utensils, even metals. The lids made of tempered glass are flat, making them more space saver. You can place the lid upside-down on an item to make that the space is secure.

Check out the full Calphalon Premier Reviews

Calphalon Signature vs. Premier Comparison

Calphalon Signature vs Premier: Which Is The Best Cookware For You? 3 #cookymom

Calphalon Signature vs Premier: Construction

One of the best things about the Calphalon Signature and Calphalon Premier is fully-clad cookware sets. They are created by different bonding layers of metal together, usually aluminum and stainless steel. And this will result in durable kitchen gadgets capable of distributing heat evenly.

But these two cookware sets have a few differences. The Calphalon Signature is relatively better compared to Premier in terms of construction. While the latter only has three-ply construction, know that the Calphalon Signature has five. Rather than just having a single core aluminum layer bonded between two layers of stainless, the Signature comes with three core aluminum layers.

With that in mind, regarding durability, temperature control, and heat distribution, expect that the Signature line can offer you better results.

Another important thing to keep in mind when constructing is the rivets. While the Calphalon Signature has three, only two rivets attach to the handles. Though it is just a minor thing for some, it is best to have more rivets to ensure that your cookware set will not fall off, especially when you’re moving it from one place to another.

Winner: Calphalon Signature

Without a doubt, the Calphalon Signature is the real deal in construction. Because aside from having a five-ply construction, the cookware set has a securely riveted handle.

Calphalon Signature vs Premier: Oven Safe

Both the Calphalon Signature and Calphalon Premier are oven-safe. Respectively, it can withstand heat temperature up to 500-degree Fahrenheit while the latter has a max heat tolerance of 450-degree Fahrenheit.

However, the Premier line’s lower heat tolerance should not stop you from whipping different meals with it. What’s more, it’s broiler and oven safe like the Signature. Meaning to say, it is so versatile.

Nevertheless, if you want to have peace of mind while cooking, you can achieve that with the higher temperature tolerance of the Signature line. After all, everybody wants to have an enjoyable cooking experience rather than worry about other things aside from what they are cooing.

Winner: Calphalon Signature

The same with construction, the winner for this category is no other than the Calphalon Signature. Based on the information provided above, unlike the Calphalon Premier, the Signature comes with higher heat tolerance.

Calphalon Signature vs Premier: Cookware Options

If you want a cookware set with a wide variety of options, you can never go wrong with the Calphalon Premier.

The Signature and Premier lines have stainless steel and nonstick versions, and the latter comes with a space-saving option. The space-saving variety comes with interlocking grooves and flat covers. These special features will allow you to stack them with ease while saving up to 30 percent of extra space.

While it is also possible to stack the Calphalon Signature, keep in mind that you might end up scratching the surface. To give you an idea of how much bigger the Calphalon Premier is, it comes with 40 cookware variations, and there are only 15 for the Signature line.

Nevertheless, before I reveal the winner for this category, I will show you the different cookware sets included in both Calphalon lines.

Calphalon Signature Cookware Options

Calphalon Signature Stainless Steel Cookware
  • (1) 8-quart stockpot with cover
  • (1) 8-inch omelette pan
  • (1) 2-quart saucepan with cover  
  • (1) 10-inch omelette pan  
  • (1) 3-quart saucepan with cover 
  • (1) 3-quart sauté pan with cover
Calphalon Signature Nonstick Cookware
  • (1) 8-quart stockpot with cover
  • (1) 10-inch omelette pan
  • (1) 2-quart saucepan with cover
  • (1) 12-inch omelette pan
  • (1) 3-quart saucepan with cover   
  • (1) 3-quart sauté pan with cover

Calphalon Premier Cookware Options

Calphalon Premier Space-Saving Cookware
  • (1) 8-inch fry pan
  • (1) 10-inch fry pan
  • (1) 12-inch fry pan
  • 2.5-quart saucepan with lid
  • 3.5-qt saucepan with lid
  • 4.5-quart soup pan with lid
  • (1) 3-quart stockpot with lid   
  • (1) 3-quart sauté pan with lid
Calphalon Premier Stainless Steel Cookware
  • (1) 10-inch fry pan      
  • (1) 12-inch fry pan with lid  
  • 1.5- quart saucepan with lid
  • 2.5- quart saucepan with lid 
  • (1) 3-quart sauté pan 
  • (1) 8-quart stockpot with lid
Calphalon Premier Nonstick Cookware
  • (1) 10-inch fry pan  
  • (1) 12-inch fry pan with lid
  • 1.5- quart saucepan with lid  
  • 2.5- quart saucepan with lid
  • (1) 3- quart saucepan with lid        
  • (1) 8- quart stockpot with lid

Winner: Calphalon Premier

Without a doubt, the Calphalon Premier is the winner as it comes with a bigger collection compared to its rival.

Calphalon Signature vs Premier: Design

The Calphalon Premier and Signature comes with nonstick surfaces. However, it is worth mentioning that there is something about the coating of the latter set. The pans and pots included in the Signature line have a “sear” surface that is relatively coarser compared to the nonstick coating of the Premier, which makes them perfect for searing and browning meat such as browning steaks and burgers.

You don’t have to invest in separate cast iron skillets and stainless-steel pans anymore. Because the Calphalon Signature does not possess the same type of texture, surely do not count on it to brown your food properly.

On the other hand, while the Calphalon Signature is winning the nonstick surface category, it’s worth mentioning that the Calphalon Premier has something that does not come with a space-saving feature. The lids of the Premier line are flat, and this will allow you to stack the pans and tops on top of one another with ease.

There are also interlocking grooves on every side of the cookware to boot. This will keep the cookware pieces from toppling over and scratching one another, especially when stacked. Thus, if you have a limited kitchen space, the Premier is a good buy since it can solve such a problem.

While the Premier and Signature lines have different features for space-saving and nonstick surfaces, they know that they have some design features in common. Both cookware sets come equipped with stay-cool handles that won’t injure or burn your hands. One more thing, they have tempered glass covers allowing you to check on your food with ease.

Winner: Calphalon Signature and Calphalon Premier

Design-wise, both Signature, and Premier are considered winners. It’s because Premier tops on one aspect and the same with the Signature line. The Calphalon Premier comes with a space-saving feature, whereas the Signature has a very special nonstick surface.

Conclusion

After the Calphalon Signature vs Premier review, I hope you are better equipped to choose which cookware line suits your needs the most.

To sum up, while both products are priced a bit high compared to standard options, they are actually great investments. Signature and Premier lines come with stainless steel and nonstick options. They are also fully clad and made of hard-anodized aluminum.

The Calphalon Signature is perfect for you if:

  • You want to attain precise temperature control.
  • Plan to cook that requires a higher temperature
  • You want a cookware set that can be used to sear meats
  • You want to achieve even heat distribution

The Calphalon Premier is the best cookware set for you if:

  • You have a limited kitchen space or storage space
  • You’re willing to spend more money
  • You want more options to choose from

If you are ready to buy any of these cookware sets, kindly visit Amazon and search for Calphalon Premier or Calphalon Signature.

Thank you for reading today’s post. I hope this helps you find the best cookware set that can serve you for many years and help you cook a wide variety of dishes.

Leave a Comment